Brother MFC-J5910DW

4384 reviews

Apr, 2024

Positive
price (320)
usability (293)
performance (263)
noise (46)
paper handling (43)

Negative
reliability (92)
size (60)
durability (25)

General overview
Price comparison

alaTest has collected and analyzed 4384 reviews of Brother MFC-J5910DW. The average rating for this product is 4.1/5, compared to an average rating of 4.0/5 for other products in the same category for all reviews. Reviewers really like the print quality and noise. The performance and price also get good feedback, but the paper handling and size get mixed views. Many are less positive about the durability and reliability.

usability, price, performance, noise, print quality

reliability, durability

We analyzed user and expert ratings, product age and more factors. Compared to other products in the same category the Brother MFC-J5910DW is awarded an overall alaScore™ of 87/100 = Very good quality.

Review analysis

(Based on 4384 reviews)

Expert Reviews

User Reviews

Review Ratings

(54% of reviews)
Show all 5 star reviews (25% of reviews)
Show all 4 star reviews (7% of reviews)
Show all 3 star reviews (4% of reviews)
Show all 2 star reviews (10% of reviews)
Show all 1 star reviews

Features

usability
Show positive (77%)Show negative (23%)(Show all)

price
Show positive (88%)Show negative (12%)(Show all)

performance
Show positive (81%)Show negative (19%)(Show all)

reliability
Show positive (25%)Show negative (75%)(Show all)

size
Show positive (48%)Show negative (52%)(Show all)

Show more features

Showing 704 review(s)

Expert Reviews User Reviews

Disclaimer:

Below is a list of reviews for this or similar products. If you think this grouping is wrong please click here to flag.
Read more on our FAQ’s page.

Showing 1 - 469 of 704 Show Reviews: in English | in other languages (3680)

Consumer review (amazon.co.uk)

Amazon.co.uk review summary for Brother MFC-J5910DW

alaTest has collected and analyzed 255 user reviews of Brother MFC-J5910DW from Amazon.co.uk. The average user rating for this product is 3.6/5, compared to an average user rating of 3.9/5 for other products in the same category on Amazon.co.uk. Reviewers are impressed by the print quality and noise. The performance and usability are also mentioned favorably, whereas many are less positive about the durability and size.

price, usability, performance, noise, print quality

reliability, size, durability

72% of the reviews on Amazon.co.uk give this product a positive rating.

Apr, 2024

Consumer review (amazon.com)

Amazon.com review summary for Brother MFC-J5910DW

alaTest has collected and analyzed 203 user reviews of Brother MFC-J5910DW from Amazon.com. The average user rating for this product is 3.8/5, compared to an average user rating of 3.8/5 for other products in the same category on Amazon.com. Reviewers really like the print quality and size. The performance and usability also get good views. There are some mixed views about the multifunction. There are some negative reviews about the noise and reliability.

price, usability, performance, size, print quality

reliability, noise

78% of the reviews on Amazon.com give this product a positive rating.

Apr, 2024

Consumer review (amazon.ca)

Amazon.ca review summary for Brother MFC-J5910DW

alaTest has collected and analyzed 1 user review of Brother MFC-J5910DW from Amazon.ca. The average user rating for this product is 5.0/5, compared to an average user rating of 4.2/5 for other products in the same category on Amazon.ca. People really like the usability and ink consumption, whereas many are less positive about the performance and price.

multifunction, ink consumption, usability

price, performance

100% of the reviews on Amazon.ca give this product a positive rating.

Apr, 2024

Expert review by : Trusted Reviews (trustedreviews.com)

Brother MFC-J5910DW

Brother's MFC-J5910 is a duplex, wireless all-in-one with added A3 print. All this for £125 should be a good deal, right?

Duplex A3 print, Programmable functions, Flexible feature-set for money

Below average print quality, Awkward and flimsy paper tray, Looks like a tank

Jan, 2012

Read the full review

Expert review by : Simon Handby (expertreviews.co.uk)

Brother MFC-J5910DW review

This fast, generally competent MFP is good value. Be aware, however, that while it can print to A3, it can only scan, fax or copy up to A4

Mar, 2012

Read the full review

Expert review by : Martyn Clayden (itreviews.co.uk)

Brother MFC-J5910DW Printer review

Brother's new budget-conscious A3 MFP dips on quality. They say bigger isn't necessarily better but when it comes...

Economic A3 printing as part of a multifunction package

Print colours appear rather pale and lifeless

The Brother MFC-J5910DW is a sturdy multifunction printer that includes fax capability, good connectivity options and A3 sized printing (but not copying). This is together with excellent controls, however, it's let down by average quality printing and...

Jan, 2012

Read the full review

Expert review by : M. David Stone (pcmag.com)

Brother MFC-J5910DW

The Brother MFC-J5910DW MFP delivers on bang for the buck, with tabloid-size printing, lots of capability, and low running costs.

Prints at up to tabloid size (11 by 17 inches). Scans, copies, and faxes. Automatic document feeder. Duplex printing.

Only one paper tray, so you can't keep letter and tabloid size paper loaded at the same time.

More Multi-function Printer Reviews: Brother MFC-L8610CDW Brother MFC-L8900CDW HP OfficeJet Pro 6978 All-in-One Printer OKI MC573dn Canon Pixma TS9020 Wireless Inkjet All-in-One Printer more

Nov, 2011

Partner Source

Read the full review

Expert review by : Francis D'sa (tech.firstpost.com)

Brother MFC-J5910DW Review

The MFC-J5910DW is a scaled down version of the elder brother – the MFC-J6710DW. Check the differences.

To end our entire experience with the MFP, we say that the MFC-J5910DW at Rs. 20000 is a decent and compact all-in-one A3-sized printing unit for architects and professionals. If you are looking for an A3-sized multi-functional printer on a lower...

Nov, 2012

Partner Source

Read the full review

Expert review by : Preetom Goswami (techmagnifier.com)

Brother MFC-J5910DW Printer Review

Brother MFC-J5910DW is a printer with multiple functioning abilities. It has a rugged design and performs in an efficient manner.

• Duplex A3 print ; • Rugged design with fine matte finish ; • Provided with multi functioning options

• Slightly over-priced ; • Print quality could have been better

Going through the MFC-J5910DW Review, it appears to be a good printer and is worthy from consumer point of view. But this printer is more suitable for official usage rather than home use. The design and the performance of the printer seem to be simply...

Nov, 2012

Read the full review

Consumer review (which.co.uk)

Good general duplex printer and scanner but could be better

(Rating Hidden)

When my HP multifunction printer died (plastic bits inside disintegrated), this printer was recommended to me by a colleague who uses it for A3 architectural plans and the quality is good. Brother make a range of good A3 printers. I must confess that I...

Jan, 2014

Read the full review (£)

Consumer review (reevoo.com)

Brother MFC-J5910DW wireless inkjet A3 all-in-one printer

Good value for money easy to use printer.

Dec, 2014

Read the full review

Consumer review (reevoo.com)

Brother MFC-J5910DW wireless inkjet A3 all-in-one printer

Works well via Air print and Wifi as well as normal USB connection. Purchased, for home use, to replace two Canon Printers which died with the all too common print head failure. Photo scanning has been very good. Will be monitoring ink usage but so far...

Bit bulky but probably not intended for home use.

Dec, 2014

Read the full review

Consumer review (reevoo.com)