Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker

140 reviews

Jun, 2025

General overview
Price comparison

alaTest has collected and analyzed 140 reviews of Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker. The average rating for this product is 4.8/5, compared to an average rating of 4.3/5 for other products in the same category for all reviews.

On average, users rate this product 95/100.

Review analysis

(Based on 140 reviews)

1 expert reviews

User Reviews

Disclaimer:

Below is a list of reviews for this or similar products. If you think this grouping is wrong please click here to flag.
Read more on our FAQ’s page.

Showing 1 - 10 of 124 Show Reviews: in English | in other languages (16)

Consumer review (newegg.com)

Great Smoker

NewEgg service was fantastic as has always been my experience.

Excellent Smoker. I am a novice to slow cookers but this cooker makes it seem easy.

None so far

Aug, 2009

Read the full review

Consumer review (newegg.com)

New smoker

Easy to assemble, great Weber quality, fast New Egg delivery. I couldn't be more please with my decision to buy a grill from New Egg

none, except my biggest problem is explaining to my wife why I need three grills on my patio....still working on the answer.

Jun, 2009

Read the full review

Consumer review (productreview.com.au)

Bbq

Multiple use. Smoker and bbq in one. Big enough for big ham for Christmas time or 2 ham. Also very good bbq. Don't use lot of space and it's handy. Easy to move. I LOVE IT I LOVE IT I LOVE IT I LOVE IT I LOVE IT I LOVE IT

Jul, 2017

Read the full review

Consumer review (productreview.com.au)

How easy is this smoker?

Bought this BBQ to supplement my gas BBQ as they get too hot for serious smoking, low and slow. Unbelievable sums it up. So simple to use, just load in the bricketts, (60) add the lit ones (40) put water in the bowl, grills in add meat close lid. I use...

Sep, 2016

Read the full review

Consumer review (homedepot.com)

Great smoker

It is a Weber & it cooks like a Weber... Perfect. You get what you pay for.

Dec, 2015

Read the full review

Consumer review (homedepot.com)

Great Smoker that you can actually take places!

Weber's Smokey Mountain is an outstanding tool for perfectly smoking any meats. The only complaint I have is the tray is held by the legs falls off a little to easily. I appreciate that this smoker can be easily transported to other locations, like...

Durable , Large Cooking Space

Dec, 2015

Read the full review

Consumer review (homedepot.com)

Great Smoker for the price!

Assembly seemed difficult at first however only took about 15 minutes. I have used it about 3x in the past month and no issues, however recommend purchasing a wireless thermometer to make managing the temp easy! The thermometer i purchased was Maverick...

Durable , Easy to Clean , Sturdy , Distributes Heat Evenly

Dec, 2015

Read the full review

Consumer review (homedepot.com)

Great smoker for the money

What can you say...its a Weber! It smokes great. I have done overnight cooks of 20 hrs. with no intervention, adjust and forget it, dont even have to add fuel.

Easy to Assemble , Sturdy , Superior Craftsmanship

Dec, 2015

Read the full review

Consumer review (homedepot.com)

great smoker, pretty easy to set up and use

assembly is not difficult. One of the best smokers on the market

Sturdy , Distributes Heat Evenly , Durable , Large Cooking Space

Difficult to Clean

Dec, 2015

Read the full review

Consumer review (homedepot.com)

Great smoker!

WSM is a legendary smoker. I've been waiting for it to go on sale for a couple of years but it never does so I just bought it and got free delivery. Home Depot shipped fast, no hassle. Smoked baby back ribs the first weekend!

Easy to Assemble , Easy to Clean , Large Cooking Space

no wheels

Oct, 2015

Read the full review